Where is the Love?: Third World within the First World

April Joy Damian | May 22, 2008 - 2:47 pm

Tags: class, gender, inequality, marginalization, race

Before Furgie switched gears and began singing about her "humps" and being "Clumsy," I had a deep appreciation for the Black Eyed Peas. A couple of years ago, BEP came out with the song, "Where is the Love?" One of the lines that struck me most was, "Overseas we try to stop terrorism, but we still got terrorists livin' here in the USA."

Flashforward to a few weeks ago. I was heading home at night, as I observed a lady take a stronger hold of her purse just as an African American teenage male came into her periphery. Almost instantaneously, she caught sight of another young African American boy, this one no older than five years old, smiled and commented on how "cute" he was. Funny how that same boy, whose innocence had captivated the woman's attention, would in a couple of years, through no fault of his own, be defined as a person to feared.

Headlines of Hollywood icons, including Madonna and Angelina Jolie, adopting children overseas, may have mistakenly been misinterpreted as being trendy. Forget about the newest Burberry bag or latest pair of minolos-- adopting a child from a country you can't even spell, let alone locate on a map, is what's in. 

I have nothing against adopting children overseas. After my recent trip to the Philippines, I witnessed first-hand, the magnitude of poverty and deprivation that my brothers and sisters abroad face. Yes, a country as wealthy as ours, where our "thin is in" and Americans, can afford not to eat, should increase its international humanitarian efforts in a culturally-sensitive manner. Nevertheless, just as I read about Madonna and Angelina Jolie, and remember the faces of the children I saw in the Philippines, I can't help but recall the faces of Junior and his friends from my neighborhood in San Francisco. What about Junior whose single-parent mom works two jobs, comes home tired from work, and can barely afford to keep feed Junior beyond what's on the dollar menu. To aggrevate the situation, as Junior grows into his adolescence, society's ill-perception of him being "the feared man of color" will hinder the understanding of the effects of his immediate environment.

So, where is the love? Hopefully, just as our hearts reach out to our brothers and sisters abroad, we can also grow in deeper love of fellow human beings within U.S. borders who ironically, are living in a Third World within the First World. 

Totally

Great post, April. Very well said. It's often said that those on the peripheries of different nations, be it the United States or the Philippines, have more in common with each other than they do with the elites in their own country.

It is very interesting to note the attention given to poverty outside our borders, largely to the exclusion of poverty on the other side of town. Maybe it's because it's easier to "otherize" and simplify poverty in places like Sudan, where they dress, talk, and act differently, than deal with the clearly complicated reasons why there are people starving on the street within driving distance.

People of privilege can easily attribute structural and environmental factors for famine elsewhere ("oh, there's a drought", or "there's a civil war", or "they're living under a dictator"), but they have a hard time seeing structural factors for poverty here. Because admitting that there's something horribly wrong with our economic and political system would be admitting that they have a moral duty to do something about it, and that's probably something people aren't comfortable with. Dealing with local poverty means more than just cutting a check to a warm and fuzzy NGO.

 

...

Agreed. In addition to poverty abroad being othered and simplified, it's often naturalized. I'm honestly not so sure that many people even ask why.

To quote a stalwart YP4 blogger: "So... what do we do about it?" ;)