Militarized Campuses: a Bipartisan Affair

Patrick St. John | September 15, 2008 - 4:40 pm

Tags: McCain, militarism, Obama, recruitment

Last week, Barack Obama confirmed what many had hoped was a misstatement made in the primaries. Washington Post:

Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) took the occasion to chide Columbia for its lack of on-campus ROTC. "I don't think that's right," Mr. McCain said. "Shouldn't the students here be exposed to the attractiveness of serving in the military, particularly as an officer?" Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.) readily agreed, calling Columbia's anti-ROTC stance a "mistake." 

rotcFlash back several months (courtesy For Student Power):

From last night's Democratic debate, as reported by The Hill:

Obama and Edwards both said that they supported withholding funding from higher education institutions that do not provide ROTC programs to students. Clinton initially said she would enforce laws to stop funding but later said of prominent schools that do not have ROTC programs that "there are ways they can work out fulfilling that obligation."

What they were talking about is the Solomon Amendment — a law passed in 1996 (and upheld unanimously by the Supreme Court) that allows the Secretary of Defense to strip a college or university of all Federal funding if the school bans/prohibits ROTC or any other military recruitment on campus.

If you recall, the LGBT and anti-war communities flipped out at this, and rightfully so.

Having ROTC and military recruiters on campus violates many university non-discrimination regulations. To create sympathy for their argument, the Post casts it in classist terms of elite universities being the only ones without recruiters. But the long shadow of the Pentagon does reach these institutions, in the form of "defense" research into everything from smart bombs to spy satellites to bioweapons. 

And the Post wraps it up with a bit of flag waving:

"Don't ask, don't tell" is a misguided policy. For the time being, though, it is the law of the land, and we see no sign that the Ivies' protest is having any impact on it. Meanwhile, the Army, Navy, Air Force and Marines defend all Americans, gay or straight.

But it is having an impact, as all boycotts do (to a greater or lesser extent). They're also serving as an example to others. As more and more universities refuse to bow down and subsidize Empire, we'll see reduced capacity for another set of Middle East (or South American) adventures, which is, scarily, still a possibility nomatter who wins in November.

Don't forget about high schools

Recruiters were always a visible, annoyingly persistent presence at my high school. One time, they took over my Senior Economics class to show a recruiting video full of heavy metal rock music and random stuff blowing up. I told the recruiter I was a pacifist when he asked why I wouldn’t accept a free pencil with army graphics. I ended up having to leave the room (in tears) because the soldiers in the video were so happy when they blew stuff up that my peers began laughing and jeering and no one mentioned the fact that REAL PEOPLE die in war. They called my house later on that year and I told them to leave me alone, that I would never voluntarily enlist, and that I didn’t think war was the answer to anything. The recruiter tried to intimidate and shame me by replying “Well I’m sorry you feel that way about your country”. Recruiting tactics are overbearing, they rely on white lies to pull students in, and they distract kids from learning. Thanks for blogging about this issue.

Absolutely - thanks for

Absolutely - thanks for posting that comment! Recruiters, especially those in high schools, are really cretinous liars.

 

A third of my high school

A third of my high school class graduated on ROTC scholarship. (Oh, the joys of growing up on a military installation.) I detest the people who speak out in ignorance about war and combat and what the military does. Try growing up on an installation where you pass soldiers carrying AK-47s to get to school and when a unit is deployed, that's half the kids in your school who are impacted.

I've heard all the recruiters' tactics, but most young people in my world see the effects of war close up and think long and hard about the impact joining will have on their lives. However, that doesn't mean they have many options beyond military service or even exposure to alternate ways to shape their lives.

And that is heartbreaking.
---------
If of thy mortal goods thou art bereft,
And from thy slender store two loaves along to thee are left,
Sell one, and with the dole
Buy hyacinths to feed thy soul.
- Moslih Eddin